Look at the front line West Ham put together this year, and it reads like a list of players who have already done this job. Pablo scored 10 goals in 13 matches for Gil Vicente before being sent to East London. Joël Piroe won the Championship Golden Boot and helped Leeds win promotion. Taty Castellanos has done it in LaLiga, Serie A and MLS. Manor Solomon was one of the best attacking wingers in the division two seasons ago. Jarrod Bowen is the league’s most dangerous wide player.
Yet West Ham’s forwards are scoring like a mid-table side. Going into Saturday’s loss to West Brom, Piroe had three league goals, Solomon two, and Castellanos and Pablo one each. Seven goals in total from four strikers, which is the same as Bowen has scored by himself. Defender Konstantinos Mavropanos had five.
When this many proven forwards fail in the same place, the common factor is not them. Pablo’s numbers in Portugal were excellent: 10 goals in 13 Primeira Liga games before West Ham paid close to £20 million for him in January. Since arriving, he has no goals in 14 Premier League appearances and one in nine Championship matches this season.
Piroe is the clearest case. He scored 19 league goals as Leeds won the title in 2024/25, taking the Golden Boot, and had 22 for Swansea in 2021/22. He has 73 goals in 179 Championship appearances, a record that made him the most obvious signing West Ham could have made for this division. He has three in 11 this season.
Castellanos won the MLS Cup with New York City FC and carried a reputation as a forward who can play as a second striker or a creator, which was how he was used at Girona and Lazio. At West Ham, he has one Championship goal and three assists in 11 appearances. Solomon scored 10 goals and set up 12 more in 30 starts for Leeds in their promotion season, and the Piroe–Solomon link was behind 29 league goals that year. This season he has two goals and two assists.
If the problem were simply cold finishing, the underlying numbers would show chances being missed. Piroe’s do not. He has produced about 3.5 expected goals from 16 shots, which is roughly what he has scored, with 43.8% of his shots on target. His problem is that he is not getting enough quality chances. Castellanos is shooting plenty, but only about a third of his efforts hit the target.
The picture is the same at team level. Against Southampton, West Ham had 29 shots and 13 on target, and still lost. Against West Brom, they had 51% of the ball at the 78th minute and an expected-goals total of just 0.78. West Ham are generating volume without creating real danger, and the forwards are being asked to finish chances that are not good enough.
No settled partnerships
Nuno has not decided what his attack is supposed to look like. Castellanos has started three of the last four league games and has 790 Championship minutes, well ahead of Piroe on 534, even though Piroe is the better finisher by almost every measure. Against West Brom, Kanté, a midfielder, was in the front line alongside Pablo, while Mukasa dropped deep to collect the ball and Castellanos watched from the bench until late on.
Leeds got the best out of Piroe and Solomon because the system was built around them. Daniel Farke’s side controlled the ball high up the pitch and fed both players in the spaces where they are strongest. West Ham bought Piroe and Solomon to repeat that, but they are playing in a different system, and they are not getting the same service.
Bowen has scored seven league goals this season, and on the numbers he is doing exceptionally well. But it still feels as if Nuno has not got the best out of him. Bowen is a player who thrives when the team is on the front foot, and the play runs through him in dangerous positions. Too often this season, he has been working from a wide starting position, with a front line that does not link with him, and trying to create something out of nothing. He did it again against West Brom with the equaliser, and then had no help. A player scoring like this should be driving a dominant attack, but at the moment he is rescuing a poor one.
Nuno has built his career on organised, compact, defence-first teams that hit opponents on the break. At Wolves and Forest, that worked, because his squads were designed around it. Here, he has an attack full of creative, ball-dominant forwards, and he is trying to fit them into a system that wants to protect the back line first.
The irony is that it is not working at either end. West Ham have conceded six goals in the last two games and have been losing early in most weeks. A defensive manager is supposed to make his team hard to beat, and Nuno’s team is neither hard to beat nor free-scoring. In fairness, Nuno can point to the first half of the season, when West Ham scored plenty and were unbeaten for nine games. The sample sizes for the strikers are still small, and Piroe’s chances could well start going in. But losing to Southampton and West Brom at home in a week points to a problem that goes beyond bad luck in front of goal.
Nuno has to pick a front line and give it a shape that suits it. If that means Piroe up front with Solomon and Bowen supporting him, then build the team around it, the way Leeds did. If it means Castellanos as the creator, then play him there and stop asking him to be a conventional number nine. The current approach, of rotating forwards and asking midfielders to play up front, leaves everyone half-fit for their job.
West Ham have spent heavily to put goals in the squad, and the goals are not coming. Eventually, the question has to move from the players to the man who picks them.



