West Ham’s goalkeeper question has been framed as a simple choice between two styles: Alphonse Areola, the shot-stopper, or Mads Hermansen, the ball-playing sweeper. But the numbers say it is more complicated than that. This season’s results favor Areola, and the longer record is much closer than it looks, but why both Nuno and now Scott Parker have favored the Danish keeper is because of what he represents long term. Supporters should not forget that Areola went a full season without a clean sheet before Hermansen took over the starting role.
Areola’s wider record is excellent. Across his Premier League career, he has made about 421 saves against 187 goals conceded, a save rate of roughly 69%. In the top five European leagues, he has kept 80 clean sheets in 265 games, a rate of 30%. In 2023-24, he made 138 saves, the third-most in the Premier League, with a 72.25% save rate.
Hermansen’s peak is just as good. He won the Championship title with Leicester in 2023-24, conceding 41 goals with 13 clean sheets in 44 appearances, and made the Championship Team of the Season. His lowest season before this one was 63.3%, in a Leicester side that was relegated. Last year the two were within about a point of each other in the Premier League.
On careers alone, there is not much between them. Areola has a longer top-flight record at 33, while Hermansen is 26 and still has years of improvement ahead.
The Slump
Hermansen’s season has been unusual. He has saved just 54% of the shots on target he has faced in the Championship, 27 saves from 50, and conceded 23 goals. That is the third-worst rate among Championship keepers with ten games played, according to FBref, and FotMob estimates he should have conceded about four fewer goals than he has based on the quality of the shots. Over his first 11 games, he saved 63.6%. In the last four, it fell to 35.3%, with 11 of the 17 shots on target he faced going in.
The sample is small and the quality of chances he faces matters, but there is also evidence of real mistakes. He flapped at a cross in the build-up to Southampton’s second goal and was beaten from the spot at Cardiff. At Blackburn, he could have done more to deal with the cross that led to the opening goal.
Clean sheets are a team statistic as much as an individual one, but the contrast is striking. Last season Areola kept none in 20 Premier League games for a relegated side, conceding 37. Hermansen kept seven in 18. This season, he has four in 15 Championship games, a rate of 27%.
Win rates are also mostly team results. West Ham have won six, drawn five and lost four of the 15 league games Hermansen has started, a 40% win rate. For what it’s worth, in the last ten of Areola’s 2025-26 starts, West Ham won two.
The Sweeper or The Shot-Stopper
Style is where they differ most. FotMob’s rankings place Hermansen around the middle of goalkeepers for sweeper actions, while Areola sits in the bottom percentile. Scott Parker wants West Ham to press high and play from the back, and in his first two games the Hammers did both. A keeper who can clear the ball behind a high line is useful for that.
Hermansen is also good at claiming crosses, ranking in the top 20% in the Championship for high claims, although the occasional flap undoes that. At 187cm, he is shorter than Areola at 195cm. Areola is the more reliable shot-stopper and the more commanding presence in his box, but his range outside the area is limited. The honest answer is that the current form favours Areola, but the long-term case favours Hermansen.
For the next match, against Preston at the London Stadium on November 21, Areola should start. A save rate of 35% over four games is too low to ignore. West Ham have conceded to almost every shot on target they have faced, and the team needs a settled, confident presence behind the defense. It would also send a clear message about standards at a time when Parker is trying to reset the dressing room.
But this should not be treated as a permanent verdict. Hermansen’s record before this season suggests a keeper whose lowest point is a 63% save rate, not 54%. He is younger, he has a longer contract, and he fits Parker’s style better in possession. Which is why Parker gave him the start at Ewood Park. If Parker can rebuild his confidence and cut out the errors on crosses, the long-term case for him is stronger than the case for a 33-year-old whose contract expires in 2027.
The bigger problem is that West Ham’s defense keeps giving up good chances, and neither keeper can fix that alone. Parker should choose the goalkeeper who gives his squad the best chance of stopping shots now, and then keep an open mind about who takes West Ham to January, when they may be able to find another solution in the transfer market. Otherwise, getting Hermansen back in form is the answer.
Related Stories
