West Ham United News & Analysis and Global Football News Wednesday, 18 November 2026
THE HAMMER TIMES

Pulisic extends at AC Milan ending New York dalliances: Here are 3 players that can step in

A new four year contract ends speculation that the American forward will ever return

Christian Pulisic is not coming home. On Friday, AC Milan announced that the American forward has signed a new contract through June 30, 2031. The four-year extension replaces a deal that was due to expire in 2027. It also closes the door on the possibility that New York City FC could land the biggest name in American soccer as the centerpiece of their move into a new stadium.

The interest was real. In June, La Gazzetta dello Sport reported that NYCFC were ready to offer Pulisic a five-year contract worth around €50 million, roughly €10 million a season, to bring him to MLS for the first time in his senior career. Milan said the player was not available. Pulisic was reportedly tempted, and it is not hard to see why. He grew up in Hershey, Pennsylvania, and NYCFC are set to open Etihad Park in Queens, a purpose-built stadium the club has been chasing for more than a decade. A homegrown American star in the first season of that ground would have been a perfect story.

NYCFC president Brad Sims was realistic about it in July. Without Milan’s consent, he said, the move was “dead in the water.” It was always going to take Pulisic pushing for it, and he has now settled the question the other way.

“This is the most important chapter right now,” Pulisic said of his time in Milan. He has the owner’s backing and a manager in Ruben Amorim who clearly rates him. Milan’s statement points to 44 goals in 141 appearances since he arrived from Chelsea in 2023.


The deal is not without risk for Milan. Recurring injuries have cost Pulisic too many games over the last two years. He missed preseason and the start of this campaign while rehabbing, and he also picked up a knock at the World Cup. But when he is fit, his best games have been among the best any Milan player has produced in that time.

  • The start. He scored on his debut at Bologna, then again in his first home game at San Siro in a 4-1 win over Torino. He became the first Milan player since Zlatan Ibrahimovic to score 15 goals in his first two seasons.
  • Real Madrid, November 2024. In a 3-1 win at the Bernabéu, Pulisic was the catalyst. He set up Milan’s early opener from a corner and helped them regain the lead after Vinícius Júnior equalized from the penalty spot.
  • The Supercoppa Italiana. In Riyadh, he scored in both the semifinal against Juventus and the final against Inter, and Milan won the trophy.
  • Torino, last season. Milan were two goals down inside 17 minutes. Pulisic, battling flu and saying he had felt “truly dead” two days before, came off the bench and scored twice in a 3-2 comeback that put Milan top of Serie A.
  • This month. He has found form again under Amorim. He scored in the win over Lecce, then again last Sunday against Udinese when he finished a Luka Modrić free kick in the sixth minute of a 2-0 win.

THREE PLAYERS WHO CAN STEP IN

NYCFC still need a face for the new stadium, and they still need someone to complete their rebuild and hit the ground running at Etihad Park. Here are three names who could do it:

Taty Castellanos

The Argentine forward once ran the front line for NYCFC. He won the 2021 MLS Cup, scoring in all three of his playoff games that year, including the opener in the final, and he took the league’s Golden Boot. Since then, he has had stops at Girona, Lazio and now West Ham, where he has not found his best form in the Championship in Nuno Espírito Santo’s setup. Reports suggest the Hammers could listen to January offers for the right price. His close friend Maxi Moralez is still at the club and could be the recruiting chip. The fans already love him, and he would be returning to the league where he was at his most dominant.

Jadon Sancho

He is 26 and without a club. Manchester United let him go in the summer, and he has since won European silverware on loan at Chelsea and Aston Villa. He turned down a Getafe offer, and Saudi interest is reportedly his preferred route. MLS may look like a step down from the Premier League clubs he has been with. But a player who needs a stage and a reset could do far worse than New York, and at 26 he is young enough to become a genuine star in this league. For a club that needs a spark, it’s a gamble with a big upside.

Jack Grealish

If you want a personality for a new stadium, this is the man. He is a Manchester City player in the final months of his contract, on a second loan at Everton. He will be a free agent in the summer, but City could just as easily extend him and send him to City Football Group’s other big home in New York. At 31, he still has real quality, and his charm and charisma would make him the new star of the league. New York would love him, and he would love New York. His agents reportedly had no MLS talks over the summer, but that can change. Grealish loves a good time; what’s a better city to have fun in?

Pulisic would have been a statement signing. Any of these three could still give New York a star for the new era. Of them, Castellanos is the one most likely to get a deal done, while Grealish would make the loudest noise. They won’t be Pulisic, but they don’t have to be.

Global NewsTransfer News