West Ham United News & Analysis and Global Football News Saturday, 21 November 2026
THE HAMMER TIMES

Roberto Martínez to the USMNT: Dream Hire or Wrong Fit?

Roberto Martinez has emerged as USMNT top candidate.
Former manager for Portugal and Belgium emerges as USA top target.

Three months after signing a contract extension through 2030, Mauricio Pochettino is off to Manchester United, and U.S. Soccer suddenly has the biggest vacancy in the sport. Pep Guardiola is the dream name. But the name now being reported as the realistic alternative is Roberto Martínez, the Spaniard who spent six years with Belgium and three and a half with Portugal. Reports describe him as a shortlisted candidate who is open to the job if approached. Nothing is official. On paper, it is a hire that makes sense. In practice, it leaves one question hanging over the whole thing.

One look at this list of accomplishments and you are thinking, he’s worked with a lot of talent. Here is the problem. Martínez was handed two golden generations and did not turn either into the trophy that defined it. You can point to a 3rd place finish at the 2018 World Cup or a Nations League title in 2025, but with the wealth of talent he’s been lucky enough to coach, was it enough?

The Golden Generations

When he took over Belgium, he had Romelu Lukaku, Kevin De Bruyne, Eden and Thorgan Hazard, Thibaut Courtois, Axel Witsel and Amadou Onana in the pipeline. That group was widely considered among the best in the world, and the third-place finish in 2018 was as far as it went. Euro 2020 ended in a quarterfinal loss to Italy. The 2022 World Cup was a group-stage exit, and he left.

Then came Portugal, with Rafael Leão, Bruno Fernandes, Vitinha, Rúben Dias, Nuno Mendes and Pedro Neto, plus Cristiano Ronaldo’s final World Cup. They fizzled out in the Round of 16 at the 2026 World Cup, losing 1-0 to Spain on a stoppage-time goal from Mikel Merino. After the World Cup, Martínez announced he was stepping down minutes after the final whistle. Critics, including Defector, have argued he leaned too heavily on Ronaldo and that hiring him would amount to a white flag for U.S. Soccer. The Nations League is a real trophy, but the era he oversaw was built to win bigger ones.

And both times, the talent was arguably better than what he would inherit in the United States.

Americans believe they are entering their own golden age. Christian Pulisic is in his prime. Weston McKennie is a fixture at the top level in Europe. Folarin Balogun scores goals in a major European league. Cavan Sullivan, just 17, is on his way. Never before have so many American players been getting meaningful minutes in Europe. The USMNT reached the Round of 16 on home soil at the 2026 World Cup before Belgium ended the run in Seattle. The bar for 2030 is not just to get there again. It is to get past it.

The case for Martínez is a strong one. He has proven he can get a deep squad through a tournament. He knows how to manage big egos. He has a knockout-round win over Brazil on his résumé and a Nations League final win over Spain. He would arrive with a long runway and no learning curve on the international game.

His teams have a pattern of arriving at the big moment with the best players and leaving with a story about what might have been. The United States will not have a De Bruyne or a Ronaldo to cover for tactical problems. If his teams were too predictable once the stakes rose, the USMNT cannot afford that, because it does not have the surplus talent that Belgium and Portugal did.

Martínez raises the floor but not necessarily the ceiling. He would almost certainly get the USMNT through the group and likely into the knockouts. The Round of 16 hurdle is where the real test starts, and it is the exact stage where his last two teams stumbled. If U.S. Soccer wants a coach who can break that barrier, it has to decide whether Martínez’s résumé is evidence that he knows how or evidence that he has not yet done it when it mattered most.

The golden age is arriving whether or not the federation is ready for it. The question is whether the man in charge finally gets this golden generation over the hump to make up for his failures of the past.

Global News