For a program that spent decades arguing over whether it needed an American coach or an imported one, the USMNT now has a better problem: a list of names that makes both sides sound right. Mauricio Pochettino is gone, Steve Cherundolo is holding the keys, and somewhere in Europe Pep Guardiola is reportedly considering a meeting. Whoever gets the job will inherit a squad that is more European-based than ever, and the decision will say a lot about what U.S. Soccer thinks it has become.
Pochettino is leaving for Manchester United after a World Cup in which the US won its group and took its first knockout-round game since 2002, with his three wins the most of any USMNT coach at a World Cup. The federation has time, but not much. Cherundolo will lead the December camp, which gives it until the March 2027 window to name a permanent coach. In the meantime, here is who could take the job.
The USMNT roster has changed. More of the squad now plays in Europe every week, in the Premier League, Serie A, the Bundesliga, and beyond. These players know what elite club coaching looks like day to day, and Pochettino connected with them partly because he had been in those rooms himself. Whoever follows him needs the same credibility.
The federation has done this before. Jurgen Klinsmann ran the program for roughly five years, and Bora Milutinovic had a long run of his own in the early 1990s, culminating in the 1994 World Cup on home soil. Foreign hires are in the program’s DNA.
LEADING CANDIDATES

Pep Guardiola: The Holy Grail
It would take a lot of convincing, but reports have Pep Guardiola agreeing to a meeting, and that alone makes him the story. He left Manchester City at the end of the 2025-26 season, saying he wanted a break “for a while.” A break is not retirement. Guardiola has lived in New York and has spoken warmly of the city and the country. The federation also reportedly called him and Jurgen Klopp during the search that ended with Pochettino. The question is whether a coach who spent a decade at the summit of club football wants the grind of international windows and a squad that gathers a handful of times a year. A meeting is a long way from a deal, but it is a start.

Steve Cherundolo: The Caretaker
The biggest American name attached to the job is Cherundolo, who earned 87 caps as a player and appeared at two World Cups. As LAFC head coach he won the 2022 MLS Cup and Supporters’ Shield and followed it with the 2024 U.S. Open Cup, then stepped down in 2025 for family reasons. He was hired in July to lead the Under-23s toward the 2028 Olympics, and part of his appeal was having someone who could step in as caretaker immediately. That is not a formal succession plan, but if he runs the December camp well, the case for making it permanent will only grow.
DOMESTIC CONTENDERS
BJ Callaghan: The best MLS has to offer
BJ Callaghan has already served as interim coach, and this season he has made his case in MLS. He led Nashville SC to a league-record 77 points in the regular season, and the club is deep in an MLS Cup run. The timing is awkward, since he is busy through the playoffs, but Cherundolo can hold the fort while Callaghan makes his way to the finals.
Pellegrino Matarazzo: The Best American Abroad
Pellegrino Matarazzo is the dark horse, and a more serious one than that label suggests. He is the New Jersey native who learned the craft in Germany, working under Julian Nagelsmann at Hoffenheim and then running Hoffenheim and VfB Stuttgart. At Real Sociedad, he won the Copa del Rey, becoming the first American coach to win a major trophy in a top European league. He has said he is happy where he is, and his club job is going well. But he has expressed interest in the national team before, and the résumé now speaks for itself.
THE FOREIGN CANDIDATES

Julian Nagelsmann: Available and Experienced
Julian Nagelsmann has the Matarazzo link and the pedigree. He resigned after Germany’s round-of-32 exit to Paraguay and has been a free agent since, and he has shown interest in returning to club football. The concern is a Germany defense that leaked through the tournament, but his tactical flexibility and ability to work with young talent are real.

Roberto Martinez: Can’t Beat Him, Hire Him
Roberto Martinez knocked USA out of the 2026 World Cup while at the helm of the Belgium national club. He was rumored to go back to Portugal, but that didn’t happen. He knows the demands of national team football, the short preparation windows and the need to build chemistry fast. That experience is rare among the candidates.

Thierry Henry: The Flashy Hire
Thierry Henry is the longshot. He is a global name and a familiar face to American audiences from his work as a CBS pundit and his time playing with the Red Bulls in the MLS. But his coaching résumé is thin compared with everyone else on this list, and the job comes with World Cup expectations.
If Guardiola says yes, the conversation is over. If he doesn’t, the federation faces a real choice between an elite foreign name who can command the room and an American with proven results. Matarazzo is the most interesting bridge between the two: American, Bundesliga-trained, and now a trophy winner in Spain. Whatever the federation decides, it will be a defining hire for the 2030 cycle.



