Italy needed a draw in Brussels. They led through Pio Esposito. Then it came apart.
Belgium equalized through Maxim De Cuyper, took the lead through Nathan Ngoy in the 22nd minute, added a third through Jeremy Doku, and closed it out with Diego Moreira in the 80th. Italy fell from first to third in the group, finishing on 10 points behind France and Belgium, and out of the Nations League quarterfinals. The numbers were ugly: Belgium generated roughly 3.4 expected goals to Italy’s 1.1, and De Ketelaere’s header off the crossbar was one of three times the woodwork saved the Azzurri from an even heavier defeat.
Gianluigi Donnarumma made six saves in Brussels, including a crucial stop on a De Bruyne free kick and a scramble in the six-yard box. Without him, it could have been a rout. Nobody should pretend otherwise. But that is part of the problem. Big saves are what Donnarumma gives you in any given week. What has been missing all season is the other part of the job: calm, consistency and a goalkeeper who makes the defense in front of him better. Whatever the reason, the form hasn’t been there, and a keeper who is 27 and has been the undisputed number one for years has earned the right to step back for a moment without it being a verdict on his career.
A breather is not a demotion. It could be the best thing for him. Donnarumma has been under pressure and in the spotlight since the age of 17. That’s 10 years of criticism, 10 years of a nation resting their hopes on one player, 10 years and rarely ever missing a match. It’s time.
The defense in front of him has been underwhelming at best. It lacks physicality; it gets pulled apart on set pieces and in transition, and Belgium found space with alarming ease. Defenders can only be as sure of themselves as the player behind them lets them be.
This is where the ball at the feet question comes in. A keeper who is comfortable receiving the pass under pressure, who can break the first line with a clean pass, and who acts as an extra outfield player changes how a back four sits and how it is pressed. It gives centre backs an outlet, it reduces the panicked clearances, and it lets Italy build from the back with some confidence instead of hoping. If the defense lacks bite, a goalkeeper who organizes and starts moves cleanly is one way to cover for it while the personnel gets sorted out.
There is no better window. With only friendlies between now and the Euro qualifiers, nothing is on the line. No points, no playoff, no pressure. Mancini is in the middle of a rebuild that has already brought in a wave of new faces, and the goalkeeper position should be part of that conversation rather than the one untouchable spot.
If the change works, Italy learn something valuable. If it doesn’t, Donnarumma goes back in, rested, with the competition made real, and the qualifiers start with no questions left unasked.
Four Keepers Who Can Step In

Marco Carnesecchi (Atalanta)
The most natural first choice. He has been the established number two in recent squads, plays for a club that builds from the back and presses high, and is used to a keeper being part of the passing structure. He is the lowest-risk option and the one most likely to show quickly whether a change helps.

Guglielmo Vicario (Juventus, on loan from Tottenham)
The most experienced alternative. He has five caps, was in goal in Italy’s win in Moldova last November, and spent years in the Premier League before returning to Serie A this summer. He has started Juventus’ league games since arriving, so he is playing every week. A proven, match-hardened option who would not look out of place.

Elia Caprile (Cagliari)
The upside pick. He earned his first call-up in the Gattuso era and has been a talking point in Italy since, with Juventus among the clubs reported to have looked at him before settling on Vicario. At 25 he is the type of keeper Mancini could build a new cycle around if he takes the chance.

Alex Meret (Napoli)
The steady hand. A title-winning keeper at Napoli, familiar with big-club pressure and a sensible choice if Mancini wants a change without a leap into the unknown. He was missing through injury at one point last year, so his availability is worth checking, but he has the pedigree.
One more name to keep on the radar is Massimo Pessina of Bologna, who was brought into Mancini’s September squad as an experimental, forward-looking selection.
This is not a call to bury a goalkeeper who is still among the best Italy has. It is a call to use the one stretch of the calendar where a decision costs nothing. The defense is short on answers, the results have wobbled, and the position has not been looked at in years. Give someone else the gloves, let the back four play in front of a keeper who can play, and see what it does. If nothing changes, you have lost a few friendlies. If something does, you may have found the piece that steadies the whole line before the qualifiers begin.



